Creating and Maintaining Policies and Procedures
- Responsible Office: Integrity and Compliance Office, Audit and Compliance Services
- Current Approved Version: 12/10/2019
- Policy Type: Board of Visitors
Policy Statement and Purpose
Virginia Commonwealth University is committed to supporting and promoting an ethical culture of compliance and accountability in which all university employees and students act in an ethical, honest, and lawful manner. VCU communicates expectations for such conduct to members of the university community through its Code of Conduct and written policies and procedures. University members are required to follow and uphold the Code of Conduct and all applicable policies and procedures and to comply with this policy when creating and maintaining policies and procedures.
Responsibility for developing, implementing, and training to a specific policy falls to the designated Responsible Office. The Integrity and Compliance Office (ICO) is responsible for ensuring that a Responsible Office follows proper policy development and approval processes in compliance with this policy. The Responsible Office is accountable for the policy’s accuracy, timeliness, and education and awareness to appropriate audiences.
Universitywide policies (Administrative policies as defined herein) require a review by the University Council and final approval from the President’s Cabinet. Certain universitywide policies (Board of Visitors policies as defined herein) require additional approval from the Board of Visitors (BOV). In certain circumstances, universitywide policies requiring expedited implementation may take effect with interim approval according to this policy (Interim policies as defined herein).
Policies applying to individual units within the university (Local policies as defined herein) do not require review by University Council or approval from the President’s Cabinet or BOV. Local policies must not conflict with Administrative or BOV policy. If a local policy conflict exists, the conflicting element(s) of the Local policy have no effect.
The ICO maintains in the Policy Library official versions of all universitywide policies in effect and is responsible for retention and destruction of policy documents in accordance with the Library of Virginia’s Records Retention and Disposition Schedule.
Noncompliance with this policy may result in disciplinary action up to and including termination. VCU supports an environment free from retaliation. Retaliation against any employee who brings forth a good faith concern, asks a clarifying question, or participates in an investigation is prohibited.
Who Should Know This Policy
All university members responsible for creating and maintaining policies and procedures should know this policy and familiarize themselves with its contents and provisions.
Administrative policy addresses universitywide operational expectations and/or compliance with applicable laws, regulations, policies and procedures and are subject to approval by the President’s Cabinet.
Board of Visitors (BOV) policy
BOV policy addresses matters of university governance and /or requires the BOV to take an action item (such as a vote to approve). The authority to determine when a policy warrants Board of Visitors’ level of approval rests with the President’s Cabinet in consultation with the president and University Counsel.
Guidelines provide additional detail and direction on university policy and suggest a recommended or preferred course of action or behavior; they are generally relevant to implementing university policy and do not supplant the requirements of established policy. Guidelines are distinct from policies and procedures which mandate actions by university members. Guidelines should not be used in lieu of policy when certain behaviors and actions are required of university members.
An interim policy is a provisional Administrative or BOV policy that fulfills an emergent need, which requires implementation pending the prescribed approval process. An interim policy is limited in term to one year or less and is subject to approval by the President’s Cabinet.
Local policy meets the unique needs of, and generally applies to or affects, one unit, division, department or school. Local policies are accessible within the unit, division, department or school.
Minor revisions are those changes that do not alter the scope or application of an existing policy. Examples of minor revisions include, but are not limited to, title changes for individuals or departments and spelling corrections.
A policy articulates requirements and expectations for behavior, actions and activities of the university community. A policy may require or prohibit an action, support compliance with applicable laws and regulations and/or mitigate risk.
The Policy Library is the official repository of all interim and final universitywide policies currently in effect.
The ICO’s Policy Program oversees the development, review and approval processes for policies and procedures. This Program provides guidance to the Responsible Office, president, members of the
President’s Cabinet or respective designees and maintains a current and comprehensive Policy Library website to provide access to all universitywide policies.
The policy statement describes the purpose, key requirements and expectations of the policy and may include reference to consequences of noncompliance, including disciplinary actions, when appropriate.
The President’s Cabinet or Cabinet consists of the vice presidents and others reporting directly to the president.
Procedures include mandatory actions and processes necessary to comply with a policy, support compliance with applicable laws and regulations, and mitigate risk. Policies may or may not include procedures. For purposes of this policy, all references to policies include procedures unless otherwise noted.
Related documents are documents critical to the development of relevant policies and procedures and may include federal regulations, state regulations, state policies and other VCU policies, procedures and guidelines.
The Responsible Office is the administrative office responsible, through the action of an individual policy owner within the office, for developing and implementing the policy, including ensuring accuracy of the subject matter, training appropriate audiences, enforcing and monitoring compliance with the policy, and timely review.
Subject matter expert
Subject matter experts are individuals who have significant knowledge and skills in a particular area or topic through extended study and practice.
Substantive revisions are those that alter the scope or application of an existing policy and, therefore require approval through the prescribed policy process.
For purposes of this policy, timely review means a required review and revision at least as often as every three (3) years (triennial review) and more frequent revisions as required by legal, regulatory and other developments.
The University Council or Council is the representative body of faculty, classified staff, postdoctoral scholars, students and administrators who reviews Administrative and BOV policies prior to seeking final approval from the President’s Cabinet and BOV, as appropriate.
For purposes of this policy, universitywide policy means those policies that apply to individuals throughout the entire university community.
The Integrity and Compliance Office (ICO) within Audit and Compliance Services interprets this policy and serves as the oversight authority for implementing the requirements of this policy. The ICO is responsible for obtaining approval for any revisions as required by this policy through the appropriate governance structures. Please direct policy questions to the ICO, specifically to the program manager, policy and state compliance, or send questions to email@example.com.
Policy Specifics and Procedures
NOTE: Interim Policy Status
This status is to be used sparingly and in the most urgent of situations so as to provide great deference to this process in support of shared governance. In cases of urgent need, such as when required by accreditation, legal, regulatory, or remedial actions a Responsible Office may acquire interim approval from the President’s Cabinet to implement an Administrative or BOV policy, whether the situation calls for a new policy or substantive revisions to existing policy. To acquire interim approval, the Responsible Office must have the interim draft reviewed by the ICO and University Counsel, then acquire President’s Cabinet approval.
- The Responsible Office must then complete all required policy making procedures outlined herein within one year of the granted interim approval date in order to establish the policy as final. If a Responsible Office fails to acquire such approval within one year, the policy may be removed from the university Policy Library and be deemed ineffective. The President’s Cabinet reserves the right to extend this term.
Creating New Administrative and BOV Policies
- Initiation Phase: It is strongly recommended that the Responsible Office assess the need for the policy through consultation with the President’s Cabinet member with oversight of the Responsible Office and the ICO to ensure appropriate dedication of resources; prevent duplication of effort;and to assist with streamlining universitywide policy making.
The Responsible Office must complete the following steps to facilitate policy approval.
- Consider appropriate substantive requirements, potential impact on university stakeholders, and other university policies either in final or draft form.
- Acquire initial approval to draft a policy from the appropriate authority
- President’s Cabinet member for an Administrative policy
- The president, or designee, for a BOV policy.
- Submit both a draft policy utilizing the VCU Policy Template and an Executive Summary of Proposed Policy to the ICO for a review of compliance with this policy, readability, and consistency with university policies. The Executive Summary of Proposed Policy includes: the reason for the policy’s creation; general points covered in the policy; information noting the stakeholder offices or personnel that have provided input to the policy draft; other universities’ policies or resources considered in drafting the new policy; and a general assessment of the policy’s impact. As part of this review, the ICO conducts the following oversight steps:
- Review the draft policy to ensure proper format including use of the current policy template and conformity with the Policy & Procedures Writing Guide available at www.policy.vcu.edu.
- Identify any additional stakeholders and recommend collaboration with other university units (e.g., Human Resources, Finance, etc.) as appropriate.
NOTE: For planning purposes, please note University Council does not meet from June to August and requests a one-month minimum period to review a policy.
NOTE: The Executive Summary of Proposed Policy accompanies the policy when it is presented to the University Council.
3. Approval Phase: A Responsible Office must complete the following procedures to acquire approval for a new policy.
- Request and receive President’s Cabinet approval by coordinating with either the President’s Cabinet member associated with the Responsible Office designated for the policy or the President’s Cabinet agenda scheduler.
- NOTE: For planning purposes, the President’s Cabinet generally meets once a month. For BOV policies only, after obtaining approval outlined above, a final approval is required and is available at the next quarterly meeting by coordinating with the appropriate President’s Cabinet member to make an agenda request.
NOTE: The Executive Summary of Proposed Policy accompanies the policy when it is presented to the President’s Cabinet and BOV.
4. Implementation Phase: After obtaining formal approvals, the Responsible Office must take the following steps to implement an approved new policy.
- Submit the final approved policy to the ICO for inclusion in the Policy Library.
- Communicate, educate and train to appropriate audiences on policy content.
NOTE: Direct appropriate audiences to the policy in effect by linking to the Policy Library, which maintains updated versions of policies. To avoid access to outdated policies, do not post or distribute a direct link to the policy.
Maintaining Existing Administrative and BOV Policies
5. Compliance Monitoring and Enforcement: The Responsible Office is charged with monitoring for compliance with policy requirements; identifying and reporting or addressing compliance issues; and evaluating the policy’s effectiveness at achieving desired results and necessity for changes on an ongoing basis.
6. Timely Review: The Responsible Office must review a policy at least as often as every three years and follow the procedures below, as appropriate. The ICO will provide advance notice that the triennial review date is forthcoming.
- No revisions necessary: Notify the ICO that the triennial review is complete and no revisions are necessary. The next revision date will be set for three years.
- Minor revisions: Make all minor revisions, as defined by this policy, and submit the revised policy to the ICO for verification and posting to the Policy Library.
NOTE: For verification purposes, a redlined draft is preferred but not required. NOTE: If only minor revisions are made during the triennial review, then the revision date will be updated; however, if the minor revisions occur off-cycle then the revision date will remain consistent with the triennial review schedule.
- Substantive revisions: If substantive revisions are necessary, a full review of the draft policy is required. The Responsible Office is therefore required to follow the Review and Approval Phase procedures discussed in #2 and 3 above.
- Retiring a policy: At any time a Responsible Office (in consultation with the applicable President’s Cabinet member) determines that a policy is obsolete, the policy’s retirement may be considered as provided below. An Executive Summary for Policy Retirement must accompany the policy when it is submitted for retirement review.
- Retirement of an Administrative policy requires approval by the President’s Cabinet.
- Retirement of a BOV policy requires approval by the President’s Cabinet and BOV. The BOV reserves the right to delegate this to the President’s Cabinet.
- The ICO will remove the retired policy from the Policy Library and take responsibility for document retention.
If a Responsible Office identifies a need for a policy applicable only to an individual unit or units within the university, the Responsible Office or policy owner benefits from consultation with the ICO to ensure the appropriate classification of a Local policy and consider any related university policies.
NOTE: If an Administrative or BOV policy conflicts with a Local policy, the conflicting element(s) of the Local policy will have no effect. The ICO recommends that a Responsible Office follow the relevant procedures above to create, implement, and maintain a Local policy, including acquiring approval from the President’s Cabinet member or designee with appropriate oversight.
This policy supersedes the following archived policies:
|May 17, 2002||Policy on Creating and Establishing University Policy|
|May 20, 2011||Creating and Maintaining Policies and Procedures|
|November 10, 2011||Creating and Maintaining Policies and Procedures|
|September 6, 2016||Creating and Maintaining Policies and Procedures-Interim|
|December 9, 2016||Creating and Maintaining Policies and Procedures|
- Who should I contact if I have a question about an existing policy?
Each policy has a Contacts section that directs you to the Responsible Office and lists the position of the person available for interpretation.
- Which policies are included in the Policy Library and which policies are not?
- Interim and final approved Administrative and BOV policies are included.
- Local policies are not included in the Policy Library. Local policy meets the unique needs of, and generally applies to, or affects one unit, division, department or school and is accessible within the unit, division, department, or school.
- What is the responsibility of the Policy Program?
Located within the Integrity and Compliance Office (ICO), the Policy Program has the following responsibilities for policy creation and maintenance:
- Oversees the development, review, approval and retirement processes for policies and procedures;
- Provides guidance to the Responsible Office, president, President’s Cabinet member, or respective designee;
- Communicates approved Administrative and BOV policies to university members;
- Administers and maintains a current and comprehensive Policy Library;
- Other Policy Program services may include:
o Gap assessments;
o Archival of policies beginning January 1, 2012;
o Email notifications approximately 6 months before timely review deadline; and
o Drafting support, tips and resources.
4. Does a policy have to go through the approval process again if revisions are needed?
It depends on the level of revisions. Minor revisions, such as placing the policy in the template, changing contact information or office name changes, or updating a URL do not require approval. Substantive revisions, such as adding, changing, or removing a procedural step, require review, public comment and approval.
5. If University Counsel has reviewed the draft policy prior to my submitting it to the ICO for review, must I submit it to University Counsel again after ICO’s review?
It depends. If you make any substantive changes to the draft after ICO’s review, you must submit the draft to University Counsel again pursuant to the review and governance process outlined in this policy.
6. What if I have revisions to make prior to triennial review?
It is the policy owner’s responsibility to make timely revisions on an ongoing basis. As business needs, laws or regulations develop, VCU policies should reflect these changes as soon as practicable. Triennial review and appropriate revision is a minimum requirement, but revisions can be made at any time and, in certain cases, more frequent revisions are required.
7. What if there are no changes to the policy, do I still respond to the triennial review email notification?
Yes, simply respond that the Responsible Office has reviewed the policy and indicate the revision date so that the ICO can maintain accurate university records.